Wednesday 5 November 2014

Session 4 The Platonic Tradition



Last night we recalled the outlines of Pythagorean philosophy as an exercise in living, the aim of which is the purification and perfection of the human soul.  Pythagorean philosophy, along with the figure of the philosopher Socrates and the body of Greek myths, all inform Plato's thought - so that's the link with this next session.  
Plato's philosophy is of an unseen world of Ideas above and within all visible existence. Our purpose is to be released from the cave of illusion, where we now sit trapped, believing ourselves to be at one with reality, whereas we are just observers of passing shadows. Leaving the cave of illusion and coming into the light of day involves unfolding the soul's innate powers and climbing the ladder of ideas into the free upper air.  For this we need to see the relationship between particular existences and universal ideas. We looked at how contemplating the little autumn leaf opens the door to a rich array of universal ideas: life, death, and ageing; parts and wholenesses; time, periodicity, succession; aesthetics and love of home. 
The character of Plato's teacher Socrates dominates the Platonic dialogues, and we also looked at why Socrates has always been an influential figure in Western thought.  He is a Christ-like figure, speaking frankly and fearlessly in the market-place, bringing philosophy, as Cicero said, down from heaven, and advocating non-retaliation for an injustice, because the soul is a free moral and intellectual agent and can only really be harmed by its own hand. There were no final answers for Socrates, but to know that one doesn't know is wisdom and the beginning of knowledge.
We read together the moving scene of Socrates' last hours in prison before he drank the hemlock, and as a philosopher departed this life with joy.  In this last dialogue with his friends and followers he taught the need to tend the soul:  "Oh, my friends, if the soul is really immortal, what care should be taken of her, not only in respect of this portion of time called life, but of eternity!"  One can see how for hundreds of years Socrates was seen both as a pre-Christian holy figure as well as a hero for secular philosophers.  (Here is an extract of an old BBC recording of the Symposium, describing Socrates' character: Symposium link)

Plato's writings influenced generation upon generation of philosophers, leading most notably to Neoplatonism and Plotinus.  Arguably Plotinus is the keystone of Western mysticism, and one of the means by which Platonism was preserved and then transmitted into Christian theology.

6 comments:

  1. THE PULSE OF SPIRITUAL WI-FI – today’s mystic (your comments welcome)

    In one of her excellent sessions on Reading the Mystics, Julie mentioned two requirements for the would be mystic. One was ‘aspiration’ and the other was that the aspirant be on a 'Path'.

    To quote Julie’s blog:
    “I think it's worth reflecting on the separate paths we took to come together - on the thinking, wanting, and willing involved on everyone's part. Thinking, wanting and willing drive the body forward each day. They are the traditional faculties of the human soul: mind, heart and will. Blended together and directed within and above the everyday world they represent the mystical faculty, which all possess, albeit unawares.”

    Just as we took separate paths to get to Fintry that dark, wet, windy night in October, we also each take different and separate life paths in our soul’s journey, but each with the aspiration of arriving at the same place. It is the intensity of the “thinking, wanting, and willing involved” that drives us forward towards the soul’s desire.

    This intensity when “directed within and above” is like a tuning in to the energy of Spirit, usually through contemplation, meditation and thought, and might equate to a ‘breathing-in’ process through which the mystical faculty connects inwardly with the Source from above. This has the effect of nourishing and recharging the soul’s energy.

    However, the process does not end here; the cycle is not complete until the ‘breathing out’ process has been embarked upon. This is when, the mystical faculty, now already tuned up to Spirit, becomes a connection and a channel through which this energy can flow and become available for us to direct into our everyday world. It is expressed and manifested through the conscious activity of our mind, heart, and will in Service towards Life’s higher purpose.

    The underlying position is that it is not my will that is being acted out, but rather that the activity is being done through me with my full participation, surrender and free will.

    If the clarity of intent is not conscious and/or self-mastery is limited, then the mystical faculty in not fully tuned in and the effectiveness of one’s action and service will be less potent.

    The breathing-in and breathing-out pulse of Spiritual Wi-Fi
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q8gK0_PgIgY (beautiful music by Hildegard von Bingen - for your appreciation)

    http://sfglobe.com/?id=2662&src=share_fb_new_2662 (RING OF FIRE - for your enjoyment)

    ReplyDelete
  2. There is a time when we withdraw but unless there is a time when we enact it in the world, it would seem to me to be sterile, without fruit.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes. We'll be looking at the Bhagavad Gita on Tuesday. Chapter 4: "Not by refraining from action does a man attain freedom from action. Not by mere renunciation does he attain supreme perfection. For not even for a moment can a man be without action....But great is the man who, free from attachments, and with a mind ruling its powers in harmony, works on the path of Karma Yoga, the path of consecrated action." Kindest Regards

      Delete
  3. What is the "it" that we "enact (it) in the world" ? - what is the "fruit" and by what criteria do we know it to be "sterile" or not?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The metaphor of breathing in and breathing out is very helpful, but I wonder if there is not also something which happens between the inbreath and the outbreath? The air is changed by us, and changes us. Like the contribution of plants to the evolution of life on earth (adding oxygen - a poison which has nevertheless allowed life-forms beyond the earliest Archaea to develop) we 'breath out' not only carbon dioxide, warmth, moisture but also this action powered by our bodies and minds.

      It seems to me that 'it' is ourselves and our understandings, which we hope to be the best we can make them through study, reflection and other processes we are drawn to. Some may call this 'soul'. As we found last week, it is well-nigh impossible to 'not act' (or consciously withhold action). There will be consequences either way! If our actions express qualities such as the reflective thoughtfulness, compassion, doing-no-harm which I'm sure all aspire to, we hope that good will ensue. I suppose that occasionally it will not - very disappointing! but that too gives us material for reflection. It is a growth process, a path of learning.

      In all this I certainly encounter semantic difficulties. Words carry resonances which are different for all of us. I have a particular difficulty with the word 'will', maybe from my 'wilful' childhood and frequent parental condemnation of independent action.

      Also, I wonder if paths (as metaphors), as well as having different origins, have different destinations too. Thank goodness we do meet along the way.

      Delete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete